
FIREPLACE REMODELING · HICKSVILLE NY
Fireplace Remodeling Hicksville NY
Fireplace remodeling in Hicksville NY starts with the wall — not just the firebox. Creatively Done Homes Improvements Inc. is based at 104 Jerusalem Ave. Hicksville NY 11801, and custom fireplace surrounds, mantels, hearth walls, and fitted cabinetry are a core part of the work completed across Nassau County. Whether the project involves updating an outdated brick surround, adding cabinetry beside an existing fireplace, or designing a complete floor-to-ceiling feature wall, Kevin leads every project personally — from the first site visit through final trim and finish.
WHAT WE BUILD · CUSTOM FIREPLACE SURROUNDS AND MILLWORK
Custom Fireplace Surrounds and Millwork Built for Nassau County Homes
Every fireplace project starts with the room — the proportions, the existing architecture, the way the space is used, and what the homeowner actually wants to live with. A fireplace surround is not an off-the-shelf item. Mantel height, surround profile, hearth material, and the relationship to adjacent windows or cabinetry all need to work together. Millwork components are fabricated from furniture-grade materials, brought to the site in finished or near-finished condition, and installed specifically for the room they were designed for.
Custom Surrounds and Mantels
Fireplace surrounds range from a clean standalone mantel on an existing firebox to full floor-to-ceiling millwork walls with integrated cabinetry, lighting, and media. Surround materials include Calacatta, Bardiglio, and Carrara marble, stacked ledger stone, bluestone, and slate. Mantel materials include poplar, white oak, and reclaimed-look lumber milled to specification on site. All finish work is spray-applied with HVLP equipment using Sherwin-Williams cabinet-grade coatings.
Fitted Cabinetry and Built-In Walls
Cabinetry beside an existing firebox is one of the most requested additions on fireplace projects. Installations range from simple open shelving to full floor-to-ceiling casework with base cabinets, adjustable shelving, integrated lighting, and media routing. Wiring is routed through dados cut into the shelving standards so there are no exposed cables or surface-mounted wire channels. Single-sided units solve off-center fireplace problems; symmetrical installations frame the firebox on both sides.
Gas Insert Coordination
Gas fireplace insert installations are coordinated through licensed plumbing trade partners under Kevin’s direct supervision. Mechanical installation and finish millwork are sequenced together so the completed fireplace wall functions correctly and maintains the required clearances around the firebox. Majestic inserts and other major brands have been part of Nassau County projects. Kevin manages both scopes — one point of contact for the entire project.
PROJECT EXAMPLES · NASSAU COUNTY FIREPLACE WORK
Fireplace Remodeling Projects Across Nassau County

Syosset: Calacatta Marble Surround, Shiplap Accent Wall, and Inset Hearth
This Syosset project was part of a larger open floor plan renovation. The design centered on a Calacatta marble surround with a stepped mantel profile set against a 6-foot shiplap accent wall running floor to ceiling. Instead of laying the marble hearth on top of the white oak flooring — the standard approach — the hearth was cut and inset directly into the floor for a seamless flush transition with no threshold, no height change, and no visible seam. The shiplap wall was spray-finished on site using HVLP equipment in a custom Sherwin-Williams cabinet color that reads almost black against the white marble.

Garden City: Majestic Gas Insert, Bardiglio Marble, and Full-Room Wainscoting
This Garden City den was part of a larger millwork scope. The firebox is a Majestic 36-inch gas insert coordinated through a licensed plumbing trade partner under Kevin’s direct supervision. Mantel height was set at 54 inches specifically to accommodate a TV above while maintaining proper visual proportion. The surround and raised hearth use Bardiglio marble — a soft grey Italian marble with a quieter vein pattern than Calacatta. All poplar components were milled to be dimensionally symmetrical. The panel-and-rail wainscoting wraps the entire room, centering the fireplace wall as the dominant architectural feature.

Merrick: Waterfront Home, Reclaimed-Look White Oak Mantel, and Flanking Cabinet Units
This Merrick waterfront project called for coastal warmth with natural wood character balanced by clean painted millwork. Aged white oak square stock was sourced from a Brooklyn hardwood mill — heavily knotted, with worm holes and natural color variation — then milled and jointed on site into a solid mantel that reads like a period reclaimed beam. The fabrication happened directly in the room using a full mill setup with thickness planer, jointer, and drum sander. The finished mantel carries real knots and grain variation at roughly a third of the cost of true reclaimed lumber. Cabinetry and adjustable shelving run on both sides of the fireplace for storage and display.

Woodbury: Solving an Off-Center Fireplace with a Custom Cabinet Unit
This Woodbury project addressed a problem common to older homes: the original fireplace sat noticeably off-center in the room. The solution was a single fitted cabinet unit on the left side of the fireplace wall — a 36-inch base cabinet with Shaker panel doors designed to match the adjoining kitchen cabinetry, topped with open display shelving extending to 54 inches. Integrated shelf lighting used wiring hidden through dados so no exposed wiring remained visible. The cabinet mass on the left optically centers the hearth wall without touching the original firebox position. Carrara marble mosaic tile surround with a raised blue slate hearth sourced locally.

Farmingdale: Stacked Stone Surround with Traditional Millwork Mantel
This Farmingdale project combined rustic stone texture with traditional painted millwork. The surround uses stacked ledger stone, a non-combustible material that rewards careful coursing and tight joints at the firebox opening. The mantel uses a stepped cornice profile with recessed frieze detailing and pilaster-style legs fabricated from a furniture-grade plywood carcass with poplar face frames and molding profiles. The hearth is 2-inch bluestone flat-ground to a clean edge. The contrast between the rough stone texture and crisp white millwork gives the fireplace wall its visual balance.
Also serving: HICKSVILLE · SYOSSET · PLAINVIEW · JERICHO · LEVITTOWN · BETHPAGE · WOODBURY · GARDEN CITY · MERRICK · FARMINGDALE
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Fireplace Remodeling FAQs
How much does fireplace remodeling cost in Hicksville NY?
A standalone surround and mantel replacement on an existing firebox typically ranges from $3,500 to $8,000 depending on material selection and mantel complexity. Projects with fitted cabinetry generally range from $8,000 to $18,000, while full floor-to-ceiling feature walls with integrated storage, lighting, and media can run $15,000 to $30,000 or more. Nassau County labor and material costs apply — national averages will run lower than what projects here actually cost.
Do you need a permit for fireplace remodeling in Hicksville NY?
Hicksville falls under Town of Oyster Bay jurisdiction. Permit requirements depend on scope — a gas insert installation generally requires a permit, while a cosmetic surround and mantel replacement on an existing firebox often does not. Kevin identifies what permits may be required during the estimate and advises homeowners on the process before work begins.
Can cabinetry be added alongside an existing fireplace?
Yes. Cabinetry beside an existing firebox is one of the most requested additions on fireplace projects. Installations range from simple shelving to full floor-to-ceiling cabinetry with base cabinets, adjustable shelves, integrated lighting, and media routing. Wiring is routed through dados cut into the shelving standards so exposed cables and surface-mounted wire channels are avoided.
What fireplace surround materials are commonly used?
Projects regularly use Calacatta marble, Bardiglio marble, Carrara marble tile, stacked ledger stone, bluestone, slate, painted poplar millwork, and white oak mantels. The best material depends on the style of the room, the firebox type, surrounding finishes, and whether the homeowner wants a cleaner painted appearance or a heavier stone focal point.
How long does a fireplace remodel take?
A surround and mantel replacement on an existing firebox typically takes 2 to 4 days on site. Projects involving fitted cabinetry generally take 1 to 2 weeks depending on complexity. Full feature walls with gas insert coordination, custom millwork, integrated lighting, and finish work can take 2 to 4 weeks. Marble and stone lead times of 1 to 3 weeks from selection to delivery may affect scheduling before installation begins.
Do you work on gas fireplace inserts?
Yes. Gas fireplace insert installations are coordinated through licensed plumbing trade partners under Kevin’s direct supervision. Mechanical installation and finish millwork are sequenced together so the completed fireplace wall functions correctly and maintains the required clearances around the firebox. Kevin manages both scopes — one point of contact for the entire project, not separate contractors working independently.
Kevin leads every fireplace remodeling project personally — from the first estimate through the final finish work. Creatively Done Homes Improvements Inc. serves Hicksville, Syosset, Plainview, Jericho, Woodbury, Merrick, Farmingdale, Garden City, and surrounding Nassau County communities. You can also see the same fireplace work in nearby Plainview and Jericho. For more on custom millwork and home remodeling, see the service pages, or read the fireplace remodeling project blog. See finished work in the project gallery. Call 516-470-1961 for your free estimate.
Get Your Free Fireplace Estimate
Get a free in-home assessment for your fireplace surround, mantel, or built-in wall project. Kevin will inspect the wall, discuss design options, and give you an honest estimate — no pressure, no obligation.
Phone
kevin@creativelydoneremodeling.com
Address
104 Jerusalem Ave. Hicksville NY 11801